Sunday, April 18, 2010

Sordid Lives: Bay Street Theatre

“Ain’t it a bitch, sorting out our sordid lives?”

Well, it most certainly is. The Bay Street Theatre's latest offering of Del Shores' Sordid Lives manages to make the best of a difficult situation and show forth a production of this "black comedy about white trash" with charm and care.

This selection is by far one of Mr. Shores' weaker offerings. Following on the heels of the far stronger (yet less critically acclaimed) Daddy's Dyin' (Who's Got the Will?), Sordid Lives gives us a series of scenes poorly sutured together with monologues from Ty Williamson (Chris Stanley) and songs from Bitsy Mae Harling (Kimmi Sampieri). Mr. Stanley offers us a moving story of a homosexual actor trying to come to terms with his identity and Texas upbringing from within the monologues, and Ms. Sampieri sings ably... but the whole thing really does not hang together well.

The problem is essentially one of dramatic efficiency and construction. Mr. Shores' script (which won awards in LA for the playwriting, somehow) relies far too heavily on an episodic vignette format where angry women burst into bars (with guns, of course) for no discernible reason. Though each bit is funny in and of itself, the overall arch is akin to a badly directed mashup between Rowan & Martin's Laugh In and The Redneck Rampage. One can sense a real disdain for his characters, and at the end of the day... (particularly if one has even glanced at Jim Gode's Redneck Manifesto) even white trash characters deserve to be treated kindly.

Despite all of this, The Bay Street Theatre's production shines with tongue-in-cheek jokes and careful understanding. The cast, under the direction of Kimmi Sampieri (making her directorial debut), manages problematic material well. Sissy Hickey (Kathy Alderman) is a delightfully focused bundle of neuroses trying to quit smoking in the aftermath of her sister's death and ensuing family drama. Ms. Alderman plays with heart and excellent comic timing. Also reliably delightful is the drunken barfly Juanita (Genie Brazzeal), who manages to portray inveterate drunkenness without becoming simply obnoxious (a more difficult task than one would actually imagine). Also of note are Odell Owens (Logan Padilla), a Baby Hueyesque redneck with a penchant for cat's cradle and boundless enthusiasm; Earl "Brother Boy" Ingram (Neal Scott), a transvestite homosexual who has resisted almost 23 years and 68 "dehomosexualization" treatments at the hands of a vampish and oversexed Dr. Eve Bollinger (Khara-Beth Chandler); and Mr. Stanley as a touching and heartfelt Ty Williamson.

The cast is rounded out by Bay Street stalwarts Valerie Macaluso and Travis Harold Coles with Gwyn Yarbrough and Peter Grffin also making appearances.

Sunday, April 4, 2010

12 Angry Men: Fairweather Productions LLC.

Reasonable doubt. Perhaps no two words link the world of criminal justice and dramatic arts as strongly as these. When seeking to convict an accused criminal, the jury must be convinced beyond this. When seeking to independently produce a theatrical work, with the requisite time, money, and effort, the average producer will want similar assurances of the return upon their investment.

This piece, adapted by Reginal Rose from a teleplay by the same title, and produced by Fairweather Productions LLC under the direction of Christopher Soucy marks the first dramatic production facilitated by Indigo Arts with verve that settled any doubt abuot their eventual success.

Contemporary American Cultural Policy is largely one of laissez faire when it comes to undertaking independent production. National Endowment and copyright/royalty provisions aside, those who seek to create theatre will operate largely free from government interference and assistance. This new production of 12 Angry Men may very well mark a new chapter of free initiative in Savannah's Theatrical community. To quote JinHi Soucy Rand in a recent interview with SavannahNow.com, "The local performers got together and said this is a play they wanted to see done." Such initiative on the part of performers is highly laudable, and we look forward to seeing Indigo Arts and Fairweather Productions assist even more artists in fulfilling their ambitions.

The piece itself is a classic crimial melodrama about the power of doubt. Though the message, the benefit of critical thought and sound argumentation, is a timely one in this age of political soundbites and Tea Party Rage, Rose's script is not without certain limitations. Closing people in a room, though powerful in terms of Neoclassical unity of place, also denies the audience direct consideration of the evidence. Though the witnesses discussed in the teleplay could be directly seen through flashback and other cinematic techniques, one is left with having to take second hand word from jurors while onstage. Further, aside from occasional demonstrations where jurors "reconstruct" events of the crime based upon their own recollections, the piece is highly static onstage.

The cast, built pursely out of local actors with grit contains notables such as Bill DeYoung, Ryan McCurdy (appearing opening weekend in place of Gabriel Ricard), Phil Keeling, Mark Rand, Al Paderewski, and Walter Magnuson. To pull together disparate elements of Savannah's theatrical community, figures from various artistic "orbits" into a single piece is an accomplishment which has not been rivaled since JinHi Rand's spearheadings of the late lamented Savannah Shakespeare Festival. It goes to prove that there ARE a variety of men in our theatrical community, it just has to be the right project.

Also, a number of the performances come down as particularly high caliber. Walter Magnuson's "Miss Manners" portrayal of Juror 2 gives a clear indication of this character's dedication to form. Al Paderewski, as the recently immigrated Juror 11, has a calm, contemplative manner that inspires a certain reverence for American due process. Mark Rand, as Juror 10, proves his artistic versatility and ability to play unsympathetic characters (see earlier comments regarding Doubt: A Parable) in this depiction of the case's most racially prejudiced juror. The ensemble cast proves itself highly capable of passing focus and limiting interruption.

Though Bill DeYoung capably and earnestly depicts Juror 4, there is a bit too much of Atticus Finch (which he played recently for the City of Savannah's production of To Kill a Mockingbird) in his manner, and some difference would help to demonstrate his range. ALso, John Turner's depiction of Juror 8 comes oddly across as the lovechild of the late Heath Ledger and an emergency alert tone. Having seen Mr. Turner turn in far more energetic performances (Rocky Horror- Bay Street Theatre), one would hope for a slightly more emphatic defense of one's principles. After all, as Juror 8 often repeats "There is a man's life at stake."

Further, it seems that the climactic scene, where Keeling's Juror 3 finds himself isolated in his continued stance of guilty, simply snaps like a damp firecracker and the show packs up as quickly as possible. Partially, the static staging simply leaves the actors to toss some form of platitude at his back, and none of these points seems to gain enough force to precipitate the violence of Keeling's reaction. In true Neoclassical style, the script has torn away all extraneous detail to allow us to focus on the struggle in the room itself (the actual verdict is really immaterial once the spiritual battle in the room is decided), but the staged climax fails to build on this platform and instead fizzles.

At the end of the day, the cast and production company (Fairweather) do well for themselves. This particular advertisment for the CSI Effect treads the boards with dignity and power, and we here at The Savannah Dramaturgy hope to see Fairweather building off its success here and helping to facilitate other artistic ambitions.